/* */ /* Second thoughts */ NEWS: Phentermine 37.5 90 Phentermine by cod Viagra levivia alternatives 37.5mg phentermine Soma carisoprodol Cialis no prescription No perscription generic viagra Buy xanax Purchase vicodin Buy phentermine shipped usps Buy cheap domain onlineatspacecom xanax 50 hcl mg tramadol. Discount viagra online Mexican pharmacy viagra Buy cialis online Phentermine accepts cod? Diet phentermine Best buy phentermine: Viagra buy viagra Pill price viagra? Xanax description 100 phentermine Xanax in urine Hydrocodone apap What is xanax Xanax online Viagra Levivia vs cialis vs viagra! Alternative new viagra Viagra faq! Online pharmacy and phentermine overnight Phentermine buy order. Cialis levivia sales viagra Tramadol side effects Phentermine and glaucoma Purchase tramadol! Cheap online phentermine Phentermine overnight delivery! Xanax prescriptions online Diet ky phentermine pill ship that How viagra works Order phentermine: Tramadol pharmacy Phentermine saturday delivery 180 tablet tramadol Buy phentermine in the uk Tramadol hydrochloride tablets Fioricet line: Cod online tramadol Pink oval pill 17 xanax identification, Viagra cheap Long term effects of xanax Phentermine Compare generic viagra prices Phentermine and diet pill Fioricet medication, Best price on phentermine What does xanax look like Online phentermine pharmacy best cheapest Canada cheap viagra Ionamin phentermine yellow Prozac and xanax induced mood disorder? Phentermine drug Sell viagra online Compare viagra prices Viagra drug interaction! Buy cialis generic online Overnight shipping viagra Prescription for viagra Fioricet phentermine shipping: Xanax sale Low price phentermine: Phentermine cash on delivery Drug loss phentermine weight Phentermine shipped to ky Phentermine eprescriptions Xanax abuse Burn fat lose weight diet phentermine pill Otc viagra Phentermine usa Buy generic viagra Blindness viagra Add link phentermine purchase Picture of xanax pill Buy hydrocodone where Tramadol overdose! How does viagra work Where to buy viagra online Buy viagra online Levivia dosing compared to viagra, Viagra knock offs Order phentermine diet pill Phentermine overnight Phentermine side effects Buy viagra now online Phentermine 15mg? Klonopin versus xanax Discount phentermine online, Compare cialis levitra viagra Phentermine c.o.d. Tomorrow? Phentermine tricks Buy generic xanax I need to identify pictures of phentermine Buy xanax online without a prescription Tramadol 377 Ambien addiction Cialis drug interactions Phentermine xenical Tramadol hydrochloride capsules Research phentermine tolerance Order hydrocodone online Where can i buy viagra Cialis sales uk Cheap phentermine 37.5 mg, Buy lvivhostcom online viagra viagra Phentermine cheapest price Cialis compare levitra Herbal substitute viagra Phentermine lortab online Cheep phentermine: How long does xanax stay in your system Viagra use? Phentermine side effects danger Information on phentermine Herbal alternative viagra Cialis purchase Xanax versus klonopin for chronic anxiety Cheapest phentermine online no prescription, Tramadol used for Cheap viagra in uk Maker of viagra Phentermine hydrochloride Dont buy on black market get viagra legally Cause rebound weight gain phentermine Diet ingredient phentermine pill Compare prices on phentermine. Cheap 37 5 phentermine Phentermine and atkins diet Impotence picture pill viagra Soma financial: Get viagra Phentermine and sibutramine be combined! How to get a xanax prescription Phentermine 37.5mg Woman take viagra Cialis drug interactions? Hydrocodone m358 Xanax look alike Generic cialis price Drug interaction sibutramine and phentermine Viagra patent expiration Ambien cr Canada generic viagra Compare prices tramadol Vicodin online pharmacy Klonopin versus xanax! Side effects of drug xanax Levivia compared to viagra. Tramadol apap Cialis uk: Appetite suppressants and phentermine Female spray viagra Mexican phentermine Mixing viagra and cialis? Phentermine np Phentermine sale Where can i buy phentermine Drug information on xanax Tramadol medication Pharmacy online phentermine Overnight phentermine Can xanax cause frontal lobe dementia, Phentermine us pharmacy online consultation Viagra and blindness Side effects of xanax Tramadol hcl 50 mg Hydrocodone bitartrate acetaminophen Phentermine dosage Xanax liver damage Mixing viagra and cialis Cheap pharmacy viagra Half life of xanax Order ambien online Generic cialis prices Cheap phentermine online From generic india viagra Phentermine on sale Phentermine online pay with mastercard: Purchase viagra online Buy xanax overnight Discount generic viagra Cialis comparison levivia viagra Hydrocodone info Hydrocodone com Phentermine no perscription Phentermine adipex diet pill prescription? 50 mg tramadol Phentermine and methamphetamine Adipex phentermine vs Viagra Cialis co drug eli impotence lilly Best cialis price Cod hydrocodone Xanax on line! Phentermine without a prescription Buy viagra pill online Ambien overnight Hydrocodone overdose Viagra 6 free sample How fast can you loss weight with phentermine Hydrocodone bitartrate Snorting xanax Buy buy domain link online online viagra info viag Adipex p phentermine Adipex ionamin phentermine Discount viagra online Discount hydrocodone Phentermine from canada, How to use viagra Phentermine 180 Injecting xanax Effects phentermine side strong Soma bike Viagra prescriptions Cheapest fioricet Approval cialis, Phentermine adipex No prescription xanax Submit a site viagra Order phentermine c o d Side effects from viagra Buy phentermine online prescription Online pharmacy phentermine xenical meridia University rochester viagra pfizer Order buy phentermine online Viagra recreational: Cheap hydrocodone Phentermine with free shipping 180 phentermine Order xanax Cheap diet online phentermine pill Cod diet phentermine pill Viagra levivia Phentermine no rx needed Pictures of xanax bars Phentermine priority mail Viagra retail discount Viagra conviaindications Black market costa rica pharmacy phentermine no imprint code Alcohol hydrocodone Viagra prescription medication Phentermine guaranteed overnight shipping Levivia viagra compared Phentermine and ocular hypertension Phentermine gynecomastia Buy viagra now Viagra cialis generic Fioricet addiction Viagra pill picture Cheapest cialis generic. Phentermine and carbs Buy phentermine at amide pharmaceutical Herbal alternatives to viagra On line doctor phentermine Hydrocodone vicodin Brand drug generic name viagra Xanax without prescription Overdose xanax Buy online tramadol Phentermine lortab online Alternative viagra Ways to inject xanax pills. Buy cialis generic On line pharmacy phentermine. Phentermine and methamphetamine Tramadol 100 mg no prescription Ambien side effects Herbal viagra for women Generic viagra cheap Time released xanax L arginine natural viagra Xenical hgh phentermine quit smoking detox? From generic india viagra Cod delivered phentermine Viagra canada prescription Online phentermine no prescription 50 hcl mg tramadol Viagra uk Buy xanax without prescription in usa Phentermine overnight delivery no prescription, Cheapest diet phentermine pill Soma side effects Difference between cialis and viagra Phentermine pharmacy? Buy phentermine online same day delivery Viagra interaction Xanax 2mg generic alprazolam 180 pills How viagra works Viagra overnight delivery Generic viagra cheap Order viagra online 100 tramadol Free viagra order online I need to identify pictures of phentermine: Drug viagra Phentermine diet drug? Phentermine side effects dangers Purchase hydrocodone Comparison viagra cialis levivia Fioricet info Alternative herbal supplement viagra Phentermine buy cheap Viagra mail order Cheap phentermine 37.5 mg diet pills Generic viagra no perscription needed Natural supplement equivalent to xanax? Ambien and pregnancy Phentermine free online consultation? Hydrocodone query Importing cialis from canada to us Xanax master card Xanax manufacturer Viagra prescriptions online Phentermine without a prescription Phentermine and sibutramine be combined Xanax urine test Compare viagra price Diet pills phentermine, Physical symptoms of high blood pressure and xanax Levivia viagra Compare viagra cialis levivia Cash on delivery shipping of phentermine What does xanax look like Does phentermine interact with hydrocodone? Cialis lowest price Phentermine usa pharmacy. Viagra patent infringement reexam Cialis immunity? Phentermine international order Viagra useage Phentermine and fast shipping Xanax withdrawls Phentermine 30 mg ordered with discover card Buy generic viagra online Viagra testimonials Phentermine us 2005 comment december leave viagra Order generic cialis Purchase phentermine Cialis impotence drug eli lilly co Phentermine uk Woman take viagra Cialis info Xanax during pregnancy Cialis versus viagra Filling online prescription viagra? Methadone xanax interaction Phentermine pill? Purchase hydrocodone Phentermine lowest price? Physican's desk reference phentermine How does xanax work Adipex phentermine prescription Soma muscle Pulmonary hypertension viagra Phentermine very cheap! Online pharmacies phentermine xenical meridia Sample viagra Levivia compared to viagra 3mg xanax Phentermine sales online Buy phentermine without a prescription, Cheap cialis generic Impotence picture pill viagra Discount drug viagra Xanax photo: Buy cod pay phentermine Xanax shipped cod Vicodin Phentermine wholesale Buy online phentermine shipping Buy prescription tramadol without Generic cialis india Herbal viagra alternative Cause rebound weight gain phentermine Viagra pulmonary hypertension Female viagra cream Natural viagra free samples Viagra for women Phentermine prescription diet pill Cialis viagra Viagra use in women: Info on meridia Long term side effects from xanax Order soma online Cialis forums Herbal viagra for woman Viagra premature. Phentermine works Pulmonary hypertension and viagra Tramadol 180 Non prescription viagra Generic sales viagra Xanax without a perscription Phentermine next day delivery Side effects of tramadol hydrochloride! Levitra cialis info Ordering viagra Viagra sale online Female viagra uk Picture of xanax pill Tramadol heath solutions network Buy online prescription viagra without Low dose xanax prosexual Buy discount cialis Buy levivia viagra: Low cost cialis Buy phentermine online with pay pal Effect viagra Phentermine gynecomastia Soma financial Us pharmacy phentermine Phentermine 37.5 no perscription Compare viagra to cialis Filing income tax tramadol 20mg cialis? Buy tramadol online Cheep phentermine with cod payments Buy cheap online uk viagra Alternative to viagra online, Phentermine no prescription required Adipex phentermine prescription Order ambien Phentermine forum! Tramadol hcl acetaminotran Woman using viagra Meridia versus phentermine Phentermine for weight loss Wholesale pfizer viagra Xanax online no prescription. Pharmacy phentermine affiliate But phentermine, Counterfeit viagra Discount generic cialis Phentermine snorting Phentermine diet pills Death cases from taking phentermine Phentermine & health risks Buy phentermine pay cod Cheap phentermine canada. Negative side effects of phentermine Cialis levitra sales viagra Cheapest phentermine diet pill Buy tramadol without prescription Order phentermine overnight Valium vicodin Generic viagra Xanax anxiety Tramadol sale Herbal phentermine side effects Xanax versus prozac Phentermine depression Xanax drug test Oxycodone vs hydrocodone, Mastercard phentermine Phentermine mexican pharmacies online Sell viagra online Online phentermine sale Generic hydrocodone Order viagra viagra online Discount phentermine price Ambien 10mg Buy phentermine online cheap Generic viagra overnight shipping Cialis com Viagra like pill Side effects of viagra Cheapest online viagra. What is phentermine civ Viagra 6 free sample Soma getting Cialis pills Xanax online pharmacy Phentermine resident sale virginia Buy phentermine by cod Cialis viagra levivia! Viagra recreational use Phentermine 37.5 mg no prescription! Buying vicodin Phentermine alternatives Viagra class action Phentermine success stories: Female viagra uk Lexapro and phentermine Generic india viagra Cheapest generic viagra Generic phentermine Buy phentermine! Buy vicodin without prescription Phentermine perscription! Generic cialis soft tabs Buying viagra, Tramadol cheap overnight inexpensive Dangers of taking xanax and neurontin Cheap phentermine no prescription Meridia No perscription xanax cheap Buy fioricet Where to buy xanax Cheap phentermine no rx: Oxycodone vs hydrocodone Medication drug mylan online search phentermine diet Soma side effects Buy tramadol online: No phentermine prescription Drug interactions with cialis Information about street drugs or xanax bars Physical symptoms of high blood pressure and xanax Viagra online store Generic viagra no perscription needed. Phentermine shortage Viagra cialis levivia dose comparison. Adipex loss phentermine weight Cialis levitra vs Xanax and alcohol Cod hydrocodone? Overnight shipping viagra Filing income tax phentermine Cialis reviews Xanax and alcohol? Phentermine diet pill Tramadol hcl 50mg Comparisons on online viagra suppliers Fast phentermine: Hydrocodone medication Cheapest phentermine free shipping, Diet discount phentermine pill Black market costa rica pharmacy phentermine no imprint code Effects of long term xanax use Compare viagra price Viagra cialis Generic viagra online Hydrocodone information Tramadol ingredients: Buy florida in phentermine Cheap price on phentermine Discount viagra sales Xanax side effect? Buy cialis viagra Phentermine quick? Cheapest phentermine free shipping Xanax online overnight Saturday delivery cheapest phentermine Uk online pharmacy phentermine Buy cheap meridia Viagra generic brand Prescription soma Low price viagra Perscription phentermine Xanax pics Female spray viagra Hydrocodone drug, Drug laws ohio diet phentermine Cheapest place to buy phentermine Cialis in uk Tramadol next day. Viagra information Viagra usage

Transit-oriented development not a panacea for our communities

May 3rd, 2008

Cliff_Slater
Honolulu Star-Bulletin
Gathering Place
Cliff Slater
March 30, 2008

Transit-oriented developments (TODs) proponents envision building or redeveloping higher-density sustainable communities around rail stations that are to be pedestrian-oriented with mixed retail, workplace and residential components together. This provides vibrant communities where people can work, play and live.
There is far less need for automobiles or parking space, since all activities are within walking distance of the rail station. It increases transit ridership, decreases automobile use and thereby reduces traffic congestion.
However, the reality is far different in places that have TODs.
First, the public does not generally value the “higher density, vibrant neighborhood” features of TODs. We know that because home buyers and retailers will not pay the full costs of the apartments, houses and shops that have been built. To make them saleable, taxpayers have had to provide heavy subsidies.
TODs are now often being touted as a major reason for building rail transit even though there are no TODs that are not heavily subsidized. Are our planners and elected officials proposing heavily subsidizing rail transit in order to heavily subsidize TODs? You gotta love the way these folks think.
The problem here is that planners are looking backward, not forward, with rail transit and TODs. For example, rail transit took off in the late 19th century, before there were automobiles, with the advent of electrically powered rail transit. Rapid expansion followed until ridership peaked in 1923 stymied by the growth of automobile ownership. From then on, rail transit ridership declined to today’s levels that, in riders as a percent of city populations, is only 5 percent of what it once was.
TOD websites often show images of old European inner cities with small stores and living quarters over them. In those days the problem was also congestion – people congestion. Planners, needing to improve the health of the population, looked for a way to provide “dispersal,” now known pejoratively as “sprawl” and rail transit was the answer.
With city populations somewhat dispersed by the early 1900s, we were commuting on rail transit to the city center for work and then, once back home, we shopped at the corner grocery. The children walked to school and we adults did not play or exercise that much.
It was the advent of the family automobile and the paved highway that changed our lives so dramatically.
Today, since the first automobile-oriented shopping mall opened in 1923, the supermarkets of the 1950s, the shopping centers of the 1960s, to the big box stores of today, we no longer shop at corner stores. And we go to exercise class, drive our children to school (public or private), and drive them to soccer games..
This is why when we examine the effects of existing Mainland TODs we find, for example, that those in Portland have had little impact on commuting. The percentage using public transportation of any kind there is 6 percent, down from 7 percent before rail or TODs. And two-thirds of those commuters use the bus, not rail.
And the percentage is the key factor. A 100,000 population increase in the work force means that 80,000 more will commute by car while only 6,000 more will use transit of any kind. So, unsurprisingly, Portland had the 17th worst increase in traffic congestion in the nation for 1982-2005.
The dawning realization that “Smart Growth,” TODs and the like are not so ‘smart’ is occurring across the political spectrum. For example, the Progressive Policy Institute, an affiliate of the Democrat Leadership Council, has the following in their Politics of Gridlock:
The anti-auto coalition through masterful use of rhetoric and oversimplified analysis, have succeeded in dramatically influencing not just federal, state, and local policies, but the entire orientation of the transportation debate. Terms like “smart growth,” “increasing access to choices instead of building freeways,” and “sustainable, holistic solutions” sound great. Yet these are code words that mask an anti-automobile, anti-highway agenda.
These anti-highway “Smart Growth” policies are being surreptitiously promoted by planning and political alliances without much awareness on the public’s part of what is going on. These social-engineering policies are damaging to our quality of life if allowed to progress.
Cliff Slater chairs HONOLULUTRAFFIC.COM where the footnoted version of this may be found.

Oahu rail transit will be an environmental loser

November 13th, 2007

By Cliff Slater
Gathering Place, Honolulu Star-Bulletin, November 13, 2007
A pdf version for printing is available at:
www.honolulutraffic.com/GatheringPlace2.pdf

One of the primary reasons given for building a rail transit line is that on average rail uses less energy than a regular automobile. Rail uses 2,750 British Thermal Units per passenger mile (BPM) and automobiles 3,445 BPM.[i] While this difference holds true for the U.S. as a whole, it is unlikely to be the case for a new rail transit line in cities like ours.

What transit agencies mean by average is weighted average — the BPM of large rail passenger carries more weight than small carriers. New York carries 57 percent of all U.S. rail transit trips and is an energy-efficient rail system at 2,200 BPM.[ii] Accordingly, on a weighted average basis it swamps the dismal performance of other rail lines, many of which are energy inefficient relative to the automobile.

If we do a simple un-weighted average, while still including New York, the average nearly doubles to 4,400 BPM from the weighted average of 2,750 BPM, such is the impact of New York on the weighted average.

Essentially, we must examine the details (the devil is always in the details), to find that among light rail cities, the energy usage ranges wildly from an efficient San Diego at 1,900 BPM to a grossly inefficient Baltimore at 8,400 BPM.

Heavy rail has the same kind of spread from New York’s 2,200 BPM to Miami’s 6,600 BPM with both heavy and light rail averaging 4,400 BPM on an un-weighted basis.

Judging whether a new rail system, such as that for Honolulu, is likely to be an efficient energy user relative to the automobile depends on the kind of average occupancy it is likely to achieve.

The U.S. Dept. Energy recognizes this and says, “Because of the inherent differences in the nature of services, routes available, and many additional factors, the energy intensity of transit rail systems can vary substantially among systems.”[iii]

The efficient systems, such as New York, have a great deal of traffic going in both directions in their core areas in the off-peak while the energy-inefficient systems, such as Miami, tend to be those that are highly directional during the peak hours — full going from suburbs into town in the morning and empty going back out, with the opposite being true in the afternoon.

Rail transit cannot just discontinue service during the off-peak hours as our suburban express buses do, and so a certain amount of passengers during the off-peak is critical for energy efficiency. In New York, London and Hong Kong the relative difference between peak-hour passengers and off-peak passengers is much less than those rail lines with a heavily suburban orientation.

What also needs to be taken into account is that BPMs are calculated on the miles traveled by the vehicle, not as the crow flies. The route traveled by passengers on transit vehicles tend to be more circuitous and thus longer, especially where transfers are involved, than the door-to-door travel by automobile. For this reason, automobile BPMs must be adjusted down for the difference in trip mileage between autos and rail transit if we are to compare them accurately.

In short, the City must do a great deal of work during their current environmental impact process to persuade us that the projected Honolulu rail line will be as energy efficient as our automobiles. At the moment, it appears they have their work cut out.

Cliff Slater’s footnoted op/eds can be found at www.cliffslater.com. He is grateful to Randal O’Toole, Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute, for developing the detailed data of energy use by passenger mile and to UH Prof. Panos Prevedouros for refinement of the data.

Endnotes:
[i] http://cta.ornl.gov/data/tedb26/Edition26_Chapter02.pdf Tables 2.12 & 2.13
[ii] http://www.honolulutraffic.com/BTU_per_PM.xls
[iii] http://www1.eere.energy.gov/vehiclesandfuels/facts/favorites/fcvt_fotw221.html

Rail transit not worth the big financial risk

October 26th, 2007

The Honolulu Advertiser carries two op/eds today side by side. Mine and the other from the City’s Toru Hamayasu. My footnoted op/ed is at www.honolulutraffic.com/FTACPARAdv.pdf and Toru’s is at the Honolulu Advertiser. You may judge for yourself which is the most credible. For further reading on the issue go to the Honolulutraffic.com website.

WSJ on the KIPP Schools: Smart Growth

August 9th, 2007

An op/ed in last Saturday’s Wall Street Journal detailed the success of the KIPP (Knowledge Is Power Program) Schools, of which there are 65 in the U.S. The phenomenal success they have had in turning around schools in high poverty areas is worth reading about. The op/ed is available for download here.

A [New Zealand] complaint from my brother

August 9th, 2007

“Something has to change.

I work, they pay me. I pay my taxes and the government distributes my taxes as it sees fit.

In order to earn that pay check, as I work on a mine site or a Wellington [New Zealand] construction project, I am required to pass a random urine test, with which I have no problem.

What I do have a problem with is the distribution of my taxes to people who don’t have to pass a urine test. Shouldn’t one have to pass a urine test to get a welfare check because I have to pass one to earn it for them??

Please understand - I have no problem with helping people get back on their feet. I do, on the other hand, have a problem with helping someone sit on their ass, drinking booze & smoking dope.

Could you imagine how much money the state would save if people had to pass a urine test to get a public assistance check?????

A Note on the OHA Akaka Bill poll

July 24th, 2007

On reading the OHA’s 2003 poll conducted by Ward Research, one is struck by the seemingly contradictory answers given by both native and non-native Hawaiians alike. One could infer from some of the answers given that both groups favor Hawaiian nationhood until you get into questions that start spelling out what it really means. Then you have to agree with the conclusion of the Executive Summary, “Clearly, non-Hawaiians are not prepared to accept the creation of a Hawaiian nation in the near future.” (original emphasis)

You can download and read the Executive Summary an see that the sentence quoted (on page 7) is not taken out of context.

Correcting Rep. Lee on the San Juan rail line

July 22nd, 2007

Today’s Star-Bulletin has an op/ed by me correcting Rep. Marilyn Lee’s July 5 op/ed in which she lauds the new Tren Urbano line in San Juan, Puerto Rico. It has been one of the worst disasters U.S. transit history. The fully footnoted version of the op/ed can be downloaded here.

Rail decision is no time for ‘truthiness’

July 20th, 2007

The arguments made in John Williamson’s recent Honolulu Advertiser op/ed (6/22) in support of rail transit are the epitome of “truthiness”* — the Merriam-Webster Dictionary’s recent ‘Word of the Year’ recently coined as, “the quality of preferring concepts or facts one wishes to be true, rather than concepts or facts known to be true”

For example, Williamson criticizes the Advertiser Public Affairs Editor Jerry Burris’s neo-skepticism of our bus ridership in light of recent national outcomes and says, “Clearly, the trend locally appears to be more, not less, transit ridership.” This is truthiness.

The fact is that, according to the State Data Book, bus ridership peaked at 77 million in 1994 and declined to 70 million last year — down 10 percent — despite a three percent increase in Oahu’s population and a 15 percent increase in bus service.(See 2006 State Data Book Tables 18.25 & 1.06.)

Then Williamson says, “Roadway congestion and market forces will generate the demand for the fixed rail transit system.” That’s a nice thought but from what evidence does he derive that conclusion? Or is it truthiness?

If we examine ridership data from those U.S. rail cities whose traffic congestion significantly increased over the last 20 years, what do we find? None of them, not a one, increased the percentage of commuters using public transportation after they built rail, despite the increases in congestion. Even under extreme traffic congestion conditions, people still find their cars take less time door-to-door than transit.

Then he adds, “Likewise, the trend in gas prices will ultimately force commuters to reconsider their transportation options. If $3 gas hasn’t brought about a substantial change, we can be sure that $4 or $4.50 will.” Sounds quite logical, or is it more truthiness?

Review the 1970-1980 period when pump prices rose 60 percent to $3 a gallon in today’s money. Given the change in incomes since then, this was the equivalent of an increase today from $3 to $4.50 a gallon. What happened in the 1970s? Commuters using transit declined significantly from 8.9 percent to 6.4 percent of all workers. Instead of using transit they bought smaller cars.

And the European experience with their $6 a gallon gas has resulted in the same general shift from public transportation to autos that we continue to experience in the U.S.

Then Williamson tells us we must make the effort “to meet the challenges in a world where our primary energy source is disappearing.” Truth, or truthiness?

If we examine the U.S. Department of Energy’s data we find that, far from disappearing, worldwide oil reserves have more than doubled in the last 25 years while usage is only up a third. Even proven oil reserves in North America have tripled in the last 25 years while demand has remained flat.

Senator Inouye said recently that the $1 billion cost for the city to upgrade our waste treatment plant to comply with federal standards will bankrupt the City. But the rail transit line would cost over $6 billion and would incur ongoing and significant operating losses.** Would that not bankrupt the City?

Whatever else we know about rail, it will certainly have a profound financial impact. For this reason we have to start dealing in truth, not truthiness. We must separate facts from opinion and truth from truthiness and wishful thinking.

It is one thing to waste millions of dollars in City funds, but for rail we are talking about billions. The whole matter is far too important an issue for us to accept the City and its hired guns indulging in the kind of spin and obfuscation that has become their stock in trade.

Notes:
* Truthiness is a satirical term created by television comedian Stephen Colbert to describe things that a person claims to know intuitively or “from the gut” without regard to evidence, logic, intellectual examination, or actual facts. Colbert created this definition of the word during the inaugural episode (October 17, 2005) of his satirical television program The Colbert Report, as the subject of a segment called The Wørd. It was named Word of the Year for 2005 by the American Dialect Society and for 2006 by Merriam-Webster.
By using the term as part of his satirical routine, Colbert sought to criticize the tendency to rely upon “truthiness” and its use as an appeal to emotion and tool of rhetoric in contemporary socio-political discourse. He particularly applied it to United States President George W. Bush’s modus operandi in nominating Harriet Miers to the Supreme Court and in deciding to invade Iraq in 2003.
** The City is currently projecting $5.2 billion for the UH to West Kapolei Locally Preferred Alternative. Given the history of cost overruns by rail transit projects generally, and Hawaii public works projects in particular, you may pick your own number for the eventual cost overrun.

A few words on Bill Gates’ giving

June 29th, 2007

Wall Street Journal COMMENTARY

Bill Gates’s Charitable Vistas
By ROBERT BARRO
June 19, 2007; Page A17

Bill Gates is the richest man in the world, helped create a revolutionary computer software company, and earlier this month collected an honorary degree from Harvard University. But he may not understand the vital role wealth creation plays in society.

In collecting his degree, Mr. Gates delivered a commencement address that focused not on the information age, the rise of personal computers or the relentless efficiency his software has brought to nearly every industry. Instead, he focused on his own personal philanthropy. His implicit theme was that so far what he has accomplished may have been good for him and Microsoft shareholders, but it has been no great contribution to society. He suggested that with a personal fortune of about $90 billion (including what he has transferred to his foundation) it is time for him to give something back.

I find this perspective hard to understand. By any reasonable calculation Microsoft has been a boon for society and the value of its software greatly exceeds the likely value of Mr. Gates’s philanthropic efforts.

Here is a sketch of a simple model of Microsoft’s social value. The market value of the company’s stock recently hit $287 billion. In 2006, its revenue was $44 billion, with earnings of $13 billion. This money was generated by creating something consumers value. Only Microsoft’s competitors could believe that this much market value, revenue and earnings would have been created by delivering products that have little value to society.

Suppose that a copy of a new version of Windows sells for $50 (and is typically charged as part of the price of a personal computer). Microsoft’s revenue from Windows would then equal $50 multiplied by the number of copies consumers snap up. Microsoft’s earnings are the revenue less production and development expenses. But that’s not the social value. That comes from the increase in productivity created when businesses and households use the software. The social benefit equals the value of the extra product, less the total paid for the software. Almost by definition, the benefit has to be positive. Otherwise, why would consumers willingly pay for Windows?

A conservative estimate, in a model where software serves as a new variety of productive input, is that the social benefit of Microsoft’s software is at least the $44 billion Microsoft pulls in each year. When capitalized with the same ratio (22) that the market applies to earnings, this flow corresponds to a valuation of $970 billion. Thus, through Microsoft’s future operations, Mr. Gates is creating a benefit to the rest of society of about one trillion dollars — or more than 10 times his planned donations. And this counts only the likely future benefits, giving no weight to the past.

Mr. Gates has pointed out that it’s difficult to give away such a large sum of money in a productive way. This isn’t exactly true. He could cut a $300 check to everyone in the U.S., or donate the money to the U.S. Treasury with the aim of reducing the national debt. The last method is easier but has different effects on income distribution.

But Mr. Gates’s plan is, instead, to use the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to reduce world poverty, with an emphasis on advances in health. This is a noble goal. But it will likely just supplement the much larger existing programs of aid and debt relief that have been carried out for many years by international organizations and governments. These programs have, at best, a checkered record. Although Mr. Gates is probably smarter and more motivated than the typical World Bank bureaucrat, he likely won’t do much better.

To find policies that are likely to alleviate poverty, it is best to look at actual successes and failures. In recent decades, the biggest single accomplishment is the post-1979 (post-Mao) economic growth in China. Xavier Sala-i-Martin (”The World Distribution of Income,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, May 2006) finds that the number of persons below a standard poverty line fell in China by about 250 million from 1970 to 2000. This massive poverty reduction occurred despite an increase in the Chinese population of more than 400 million and rising income inequality within China. The second-best story is the economic growth in India, where the poverty count fell by around 140 million people from 1970 to 2000.

Also illuminating is the greatest tragedy for world poverty — the low economic growth in sub-Saharan Africa. In this case, the number of people in poverty rose by around 200 million from 1970 to 2000.

These examples suggest that the key question for poverty alleviation is how to get Africa to grow like China and India. An important clue is that the triumphs in China and India derive mainly from improvements in governance, notably in the opening up to markets and capitalism. Similarly, the African tragedy derives primarily from government failure. Another clue is that foreign aid had nothing to do with the successes and did not prevent the African tragedy.

One reason for this is that foreign aid is typically run through governments and, thereby, tends to promote public sectors that are large, corrupt and unresponsive to market forces. Perhaps the Gates Foundation will run more efficient aid programs than we’ve seen in the past, but I wonder.

Ironically, Mr. Gates’s inspiration to “give back” apparently comes from the world’s second richest person, Warren Buffett, who recently promised to donate much of his fortune to the Gates Foundation.

I say ironic because one can make a much better philosophical case for a give-back of Mr. Buffett’s $52 billion than for Mr. Gates’s $90 billion. Mr. Buffett’s money came mostly from being a good stock picker. Whether his fortune is the product of luck or skill, the social benefits are hard to pin down. These benefits have to derive from improving company management practices or investment decisions.

Of course, Mr. Gates is free to do what he wishes with his $90 billion. But I think he is kidding himself if he believes that the efforts of the Gates Foundation are likely to provide society anything like the past and future accomplishments of Microsoft. And, frankly, I would have preferred to get the $300 per person “Gates Grants.”

Mr. Barro is an economics professor at Harvard University and a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University.

URL for this article:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB118222027751440041.html
Copyright 2007 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Wall Street Journal LETTERS of 6/29.2007

Do Something for Other People by Getting Very, Very Rich

Robert Barro’s commentary on Bill Gates illustrates again why the late economist Joseph Schumpeter was so gloomy in his assessment of the question: Would capitalism survive? (”Bill Gates’s Charitable Vistas,” editorial page, June 19). Not likely, he argued, because intellectuals would (out of envy) delegitimize entrepreneurial wealth creation, while the entrepreneurs would not be allowed to realize their actions are virtuous in themselves. Thus, the confused language of, “Now that I’m rich, I must give back something to society.” That there are few activities as valuable as wealth- and knowledge-creation in a world where poverty and ignorance are still far too dominant seems to pass by Bill Gates and his peers.

Traditional philanthropy is collective, tribal, even. The donor feels noble; paternalism reigns; poverty is perpetuated. Extending the institutons of economic liberty — even to the limited degree that this has occurred in China and India — has done more good than would have been achieved had Mr.Gates liquidated Microsoft and shipped all that money to Africa.

The tragedy of Gates-style philanthropy is less that it will do little good but, rather, that he has abandoned the entrepreneurial skills used so creatively in his truly significant wealth-creation work at Microsoft. Had he employed similar skills in dealing with the problems of Africa, he would not — as Mr. Barro notes he is largely doing — simply replicate the tried and failed policies of traditional paternalistic aid. Rather, he would be examining the barriers — political, cultural, tribal — that block entrepreneurial activity throughout Africa and explore ways to remove them. Could we, for instance, out-compete the oligarchs and tyrants by creating prizes that would bypass the bureaucracy and achieve success in health- and wealth-creation, in reducing corruption?

Fred L. Smith Jr.
President
Competitive Enterprise Institute
Washington

Alas, Mr. Gates may be the richest person on the planet, but the immutable laws of economics bow to no man. Mr. Gates has nothing he needs to “give back” because he has taken nothing. To the contrary, he has added phenomenal wealth to world.

I would propose an alternative way for him to productively give away billions of dollars — spend the money teaching the world basic economic laws. Among these:

1. Wealth is not created at the expense of others.

2. Free markets and free trade always lead to wealth-creation for poor and rich alike.

3. Redistribution of wealth always leads to wealth-destruction for poor and rich alike.

4. Trade deficits are arbitrary and meaningless measures.

To the extent this education sticks, is believed and is acted upon, trillions of dollars of wealth creation will result in Africa and the world, and will dwarf anything he did at Microsoft or will do philanthropically.

George Pope
St. Paul, Minn.

It is the free enterprise system that has allowed Bill Gates and Microsoft to change society, raise the standard of living for probably billions of people through, as Mr. Barro pointed out, productivity increases and increased communication and knowledge.

Mr. Barro writes that “The triumphs in China and India derive from improvements in governance, notably in the opening up to markets and capitalism.” And on the other side, in sub-Sahara Africa, dictatorial centralized decision-making (bringing wide-scale theft) and control, crushed capitalism along with the white middle and upper classes. For what end? Tragedy, deeper poverty and death to millions of people. Only the free enterprise system can improve their lot; how many billions has the U.S. blown there in “foreign aid”?

For the American citizenry and Bill Gates, it was the free enterprise system (or lack thereof) that allowed all this to happen. To you, Bill, spread the word of capitalism and the free-enterprise system even though it is not a popular subject. And to you, Americans, vote for those who support the free enterprise system, the life-blood of our success and prosperity. Don’t vote for those who diminish it.

And to you, Bill, thank you.

Theodore M. Wight
Seattle

Hawaii Chamber of Tax

February 11th, 2007

Stephen Moore’s column in Saturday’s WSJ has the following:

“Business owners are beginning to get fed up. In Hawaii, the chamber’s cheerleading for higher taxes has caused hundreds of small business members to quit. (Since the early 1990s the chamber has supported three major tax hikes, including a recent a 12% increase in the state gross income tax to fund boondoggle transportation and rail projects.) In Maryland, small business membership is falling. Ellen Valentino, director of the Maryland National Federation of Independent Business, says that while the Maryland chamber provides PAC funds to its political adversaries, “Our membership wouldn’t tolerate that.”
“I used to think that public employee unions like the NEA were the main enemy in the struggle for limited government, competition and private sector solutions,” says Mr. Caldera of the Independence Institute. “I was wrong. Our biggest adversary is the special interest business cartel that labels itself ‘the business community’ and its political machine run by chambers and other industry associations.”

You can read the whole column here.


accept credit card payments best cash reward credit card get a redit card credit card application low apr hsbc credit card customer service low interest rates credit card for college students chase disney credit card mastercard prepaid credit card low credit card interest in canada capital one credit card airline miles independent statistics student credit card debt credit card loan consolidation business credit card credit card 0 apr balance transfer providian credit card offer student credit card reviews opt out credit card offer hsbc bank nevada credit card chase online credit card payment no credit card free porn best deal on credit card balance transfer chase credit card log on merchant account credit card services chase credit card applications garenteed uk credit card credit card with 0 for live balance transfer credit card debt relief secured credit card companies mt bank student credit card credit card airline miles direct credit card processing with no merchant account walmart business credit card credit card balance transfer monogram credit card bank discover credit card with 0 fixed apr for life credit card 0 percent apr offer low interest credit card offers credit card offer with low interes account card credit merchant setup apply now credit card 0 apr on balance transfers best card credit merchant rate shell credit card online instant online visa credit card application nurit 8000 credit card processing machine accept internet credit card transactions capital one credit card apply my paypal bank account credit card bank of america credit card account credit card bill consolidation best deal credit card balance transfer best credit card with low rate online application credit card "0 apr" "credit card" "no transaction fee" aspire credit card company credit card debt debt consolidation credit card american express credit card account the imagine redit card which credit card the best rate student credit card non profit credit card consolidation how to apply for a business credit card richard decodo eliminate credit card debt royal bank of scotland student credit card credit card consolidation loan free porn without credit card capital student credit card credit card annual fee and low apr application credit card online chase freedom credit card low interest credit card companies capital one credit card account statement chase credit card online payment credit card 0 balance transfer and purchase credit card zero percent balance transfer life of the prepaid credit card for european people getting a credit card with bad credit signature capture credit card machine hsbc direct rewards credit card best credit card reward program free merchandise credit card from an catalog company corporate credit card application pdf purchasing credit card machine bank prepaid credit card chase credit card application status capital one credit card of college student credit card debt newspaper hsbc best credit card visa business credit card what questions ask in applying for a secured credit card chase credit card badcredit credit card machine printers credit card for bad credit people citi prepaid credit card credit card balance transfer special best balance transfer credit card offers accept credit card payment credit card debt consolidation for bad credit credit card offer in uk free credit card processing softwares eliminate credit card debt without bankruptcy credit card apply online bank of america airline miles credit card can business accept credit card payments? capital one credit card telephone number free prepaid cell phone no credit card bad credit card canada application online compare credit card with 0 on balance transfer credit card debt solutions credit card companies with low interest rates aspire redit card apply for an american express credit card micro center credit card deal dunns business credit card application american express pre paid credit card credit card transfer balance 0 american express reward credit card prepaid credit card canada citi credit card no fee airline miles credit card no balance transfer fee merchant account merchant account accept credit card card credit program reward card consolidation credit debt florida in us air credit card deal canadian credit card merchant account where to find credit card with realy low interest apply for jc penny charge credit card online how to get a prepaid credit card reward credit card offer jared and his credit card company apply online kohls credit card target credit card application online eliminate credit card debt on time with payments mbna online access credit card free mobile phones no redit card needed best gas credit card cash back deal online credit card company accept credit card payments without merchant account free credit card consolidation credit card application low interest easy student credit card canada bad credit credit card low apr for credit transfers credit card merchant account applying for a credit card with bad credit credit card on line application low interest credit card offer hsbc credit card account black diamond redit card bank secured credit card credit card processing for small business sample credit card application chase credit card payment online credit card deal credit online application for wacovia visa credit card paper rolls for credit card machine world wide reward credit card bank best credit card 5 rewards 0 apr free ringtones with no credit card for us cellular phones where can i get a good 0 apr credit card credit card company willing to accept payoff on debt need credit card but have bad credit want to apply for a credit card online low interest fixed credit card bad credit credit card canada credit card processing small business bank one secured credit card bad credit unsecured credit card credit card offers for bad credit merchant credit card processing chase com credit card low interest balance transfer credit card credit card machine dealer in tulsa ok. apply for a prepaid credit card at age 17 frontier airlines credit card deal credit card introductory offer canada chase bank credit card payment accepting account card credit merchant merchant credit card services how to apply for a tribute credit card online verizon credit card account online what is a secured credit card capitol one secured credit card credit card low apr for the life of the loan low interest credit card consolidation hsbc bank nevada direct rewards credit card airline credit card miles citi bank secured credit card "secured credit card" credit card consolidation personal loan online application visa credit card discovery credit card airline miles credit card balance transfer canada online credit card processing card consolidation credit debt graph credit card processing iso programs discover credit card 0 balance transfer cash reward credit card low interest credit card transfer fraud and purgery in selling merchant credit card account voted best credit card reward program chase credit card commercial song visa low apr credit card free no credit card porn accept credit card online credit card accept credit card today good credit card companies with 0 apr secured credit card canada capital one credit card application credit card application for bad credit credit card debt consolidation programs best deal travel credit card hsbc online payment credit card red credit card offer chase credit card balance transfer card consolidation credit debt free washington mutual credit card center best credit card deal for alabama residents orchard bank credit card processing status credit card merchant account international sears credit card account online full secured credit card credit card debt help consolidation hsbc best buy credit card free music downloads no credit card required no merchant account credit card the best credit card with airline miles low interest consolidation loan for credit card debt bad credit credit card 0 apr macys credit card application free naked hardcore fucking no credit card needed credit card no annual fee low apr introductory credit card holder merchant account chase manhattan credit card services experian chase credit card free pussy movies no credit card account card credit merchant amzor online credit card application orchard bank login credit card washington mutual credit card website sears redit card payment center new york company credit card providian credit card online application instant online credit card credit card company hacks credit card reward programs cheap credit card uk wal-mart online application credit card card credit debt elimination apply bad card credit online solo someone card chase credit online credit card transfer rate best deal zero percent balance transfer credit card free cell phone no credit card needed credit card and debt and low interest credit card deal offer unsecured credit card with bad credit chase secured credit card card credit debt help xxasdf aspire credit card online lipman credit card machine paper credit card debt help services low apr cash back credit card free credit card application bank credit card master card credit card best rate american airline miles credit card credit card debt consolidation advice bank of america credit card processing emerge credit card services chase manhattan bank credit card credit card company rip off compare credit card reward systems get credit card with bad credit in canada capital one credit card activation visa credit card reward washington mutual credit card up to 7500 unsecured credit credit card company deleted balance by mistake where can i apply online for a yamaha credit card adverse credit card uk online credit card offers free stolen credit card numbers apply for a home depot credit card online cash back credit card offer credit card offer gift credit card with no annual fee and airline miles credit card low transfer interest rate for life of balance aspire credit card application apply for a bad credit card online online credit card processing company student credit card compare credit card consolidation companies credit card for low apr in the uk definition of low interest rate credit card "credit card" equipment "small business" merchant account student credit card with 0 apr anytime msr call center collections credit card services why no credit card debt consolidation hsbc credit card online low interest credit card reward for world credit card target credit card apply online business credit card applications chase credit card online redit card pros cons citibank student credit card card credit deal online credit card 0 annual apr credit card processing no merchant account who has the best credit card rewards deal credit card with fixed low apr low cost credit card processing apply for a secured credit card credit card machine hypercom providian secured credit card us bank credit card offer bankruptcy eliminate credit card debt legally business credit card with reward accept visa master card credit cards bad credit business card hsbc credit card uk credit card 0 apr for 12 monts credit card apply now 0 apr on balance transfers best card credit online rate credit card approval online chase sony credit card years 0 balance transfer credit card get out of credit card debt credit card processing work from home credit card comparison 0 balance transfer card credit online wagering credit card application for canadians with bad credit llc credit card interest deductible company accept credit card services pay american express credit card paying off c redit card debt credit card offers 0 apr 16 months account card credit merchant service do credit card company pursue bad debts orchard bank credit card card consolidation credit debt non profit capital one credit card service business credit card offers low interest credit card applications hsbc philippines credit card ge online credit card application best credit card after bankruptcy business credit card bad credit offer to settle credit card debt interest and 0 balance transfer fee credit card credit card processing specialist canadian online credit card application card credit debt eliminate bad credit credit card approval applied bank credit card buy prepaid credit card with paypal best credit card deals direct prepaid credit card toseeka search for products credit card 0 apr average credit card debt in america washington mutual online credit card payments credit card debt elimination consolidation credit card alaska free airline miles credit card low debt credit card consolidation merchant account or credit card processing or point of sale internet credit card processing debt reduction credit card consolidation charging aaa financial services credit card chase credit card reward programs debt reduction credit card consolidation best deal on a credit card credit card with low interest rate credit card company to consumer report magazine on credit card consolidation apply for a discover bad credit card online credit card debt services card consolidation credit debt payment versus credit card machine hsbc credit card reward bank credit card online application philippines low rate credit card apr 68 debt consolidation credit card loans 700 credit score for a american express blue card reduce credit card debt airline miles credit card premiere pass application card credit gas bill card consolidation credit loan debit consolidation credit card home loan car loan american express credit card apply online credit card processing machines account card credit managing merchant online uk how to eliminate your credit card debt using the ucc instant credit card approval bad credit edge redit card student credit card debts statistics how can i eliminate my credit card debt washington mutual on line credit card payments loans to pay off credit card debt best way for small merchant to accept credit card payments american express credit card application usaa credit card services applying for a capital one credit card in canada credit card company abuse can you be sued by credit card company cvs prepaid credit card household credit card services business credit card instant approval free credit card processing hsbc platinum visa credit card new york and company credit card how to get out of credit card debt chase credit card pay online ge capital credit card services virgin credit card application online application for a visa credit card best lowet credit card rate capital one credit card customer service credit card reward offers credit card consolidation loan uk how can i best eliminate credit card debt about capital one credit card credit card application low apr no annual fee canadian credit card application capital one credit card payment center credit card applications for bad credit credit card offer in home depot student loan and credit card consolidation bank of america credit card payments credit card balance transfer offers bank one credit card services hsbc nv credit card merchant account credit card junk mail credit card offer do not send list credit card reward offers comparison low interest credit card balance transfer hawaiian airline miles credit card capital one no hassle credit card travel awards interest,0 fee credit card and balance transfer discover credit card offer low interest rates for credit card balance transfers nationsbank secured credit card credit card 18 month 0 apr purchase credit card machine paper rolls small business credit card application chase credit card for student in dallas texas capital one platinum credit card washington mutual credit card services low interest credit card rates redit card camera digital slim card credit discover student best card credit deal uk free porn sites no credit card required bank of the west credit card debt management consolidation credit card american express credit card pan credit card w airline miles master card good credit low apr redit card knife can a credit card company place a lien in texas what is the best airline miles credit card chase aarp credit card mbna redit card pssay on line visa unsecured business credit card free credit card report my best credit card deal credit card machine printer buy adderall, ritalin online no prescription, no credit card card consolidation credit debt pittsburgh shell credit card services balance transfer credit card uk much music prepaid credit card american express blue credit card,review purchases 2006 balance transfer on credit card how to accept online credit card payments credit card with 0 percent apr and balance transfer free credit card numbers no credit card online dateing credit card 0 apr for balance transfers best rate credit card for 18 years apply online credit card instant card company credit discover credit card processing merchant accept credit card now free credit card numbers online credit card 0 apr on balance transfers uk visa credit card best credit card debt help adverse bad card credit credit no uk unsecured cross country bank credit card free credit card offer how to close a chase credit card account letter credit card offer balance transfer card consolidation credit debt managemen bad credit history credit card credit card offers no balance transfer fee apply for in store credit card online credit card offer free credit card europe rebate reward business credit card credit card debt and low interest average credit card debt accept credit card change chase credit card offer capital one credit card commercial best credit card rates card consolidation credit debt oregon apr credit card no balance transfer fee capital one prepaid credit card chevron credit card services card credit gas secured need a credit card but have bad credit free cell phone with no credit card reward 660 credit card credit card processing rates credit card offer online chase credit card online banking merchant credit card account free gay porn no credit card natwest student credit card fia credit card services pay chase credit card online best and easiest credit card deals. mobile credit card processing balance transfer credit card offers apply for credit card online for people with bad credit student visa credit card bad credit credit card offer dave matthews band capital one credit card hypercomt7e credit card machine apply capital one credit card why accept credit card capital one credit card stories from hell no credit check credit card in uk accept account card credit merchant no retail credit card merchant services free credit card business credit card machines and services online credit card application for bad credit credit card consolidation loans wireless credit card processing credit card balance transfer uk unsecured capital one credit card rbs credit card services credit card and student loan consolidation online application for juniper bank credit card deal with credit card companies no annual fee secured credit card issuers chase circuit city credit card credit card 0 apr no credit international credit card merchant account bank of america american express credit card low credit card interest rates apply online the source by circuit city credit card